Historical figure: Doesn’t sleep with 200 different women and doesn’t cheat on his wife.
Historians: IT SAYS YOU’RE GAY.
The image is the central panel of The Temptation of St. Anthony by Hieronymus Bosch (c. 1501, Museu Nacional de Arte Antiga, Lisbon) — the nightmarish scene where demons and monsters swarm around the hermit saint, who remains serene and faithful while the world throws every temptation it has at him.
Which makes the pairing perfect. St. Anthony is the patron saint of resisting temptation — he sat in the desert for decades, faithful and celibate, and the demons showed up to test him anyway. The modern historian in this meme is the demon: the moment a historical figure has no documented trail of scandal, no rumored mistresses, no 200 different women, the archives must be hiding something. A man who loved his wife faithfully? IT SAYS YOU’RE GAY.
It’s the exact reverse of the old ‘historians will say they were roommates’ joke. Two men living together for 40 years, sharing a bed, writing love letters: ‘just good friends, possibly roommates.’ One man who stayed loyal to one woman his whole life: ‘clearly gay, the evidence is overwhelming.’ The standards are inverted depending on which conclusion makes a better story.
And there is a kernel of real history in the joke: ‘confirmed bachelor’ was a euphemism, silence was a closet, and many historians DO read between the lines because the sources force them to. But the meme’s punchline is that the discipline’s reflex has become parody — every figure without a sex scandal is retroactively diagnosed, while the actual evidence gets ignored.
Bosch’s St. Anthony is serene amid the demons because he knows what he is and what he believes. The meme suggests the only people more tempted than St. Anthony are the historians examining his life — and their temptation is to see a scandal in every virtue. The demons are in the archive, and they all write footnotes.
0 Comments